Why Don't Banks Like Barndominiums? (2024)

Despite the growing popularity of barndominiums for their cost-effectiveness, versatility, and stylish design, securing financing for them can present challenges. It can be down Right Difficult to be perfectly blunt. This attitude towards Barndominiums stem from several factors related to the banking and financing industries’ preconceived perceptions and policies regarding non-traditional residential properties. Here’s a detailed look into why banks might be hesitant to finance barndominiums and the intricacies of bank loan approval in this context.

Appraisal and Valuation Issues

One of the most significant hurdles in securing financing for a barndominium is the challenge of obtaining an accurate appraisal. Banks require appraisals to determine the property’s value, which in turn, informs their lending decisions. Because barndominiums are relatively unique and fewer in number compared to traditional homes, finding comparable sales (comps) necessary for accurate valuation is difficult. Without reliable comps, banks face uncertainty in assessing the true market value of a barndominium, making them less inclined to offer financing.

Marketability and Resale Value

Banks consider the resale value and marketability of a property when approving loans. Traditional homes, with their widespread appeal and demand, are seen as less risky investments. Barndominiums, on the other hand, cater to a niche market. Their unique style and the fact that they’re often located in rural or semi-rural areas can limit potential buyers. This perceived risk of difficulty in selling the property, should the need arise, makes banks wary of offering loans for barndominiums.

Zoning and Regulatory Challenges

Another complicating factor for financing barndominiums is the zoning and regulatory environment. Barndominiums can sometimes fall into a gray area between residential and agricultural or commercial zoning regulations. This ambiguity can pose challenges for banks, as the potential for zoning disputes or non-compliance with local regulations adds a layer of risk. Furthermore, some municipalities may have stringent requirements or lack clear guidelines for barndominiums, complicating the approval and construction process.

Construction and Durability Perceptions

Despite many barndominiums being constructed with high-quality materials and modern techniques, there’s a perception among some lenders that these structures may not be as durable or long-lasting as traditional homes. Concerns about the structural integrity of a metal building, potential for damage from environmental factors, and overall longevity can influence a bank’s decision. Additionally, because barndominiums often involve a combination of residential and workshop or agricultural spaces, there may be concerns about wear and tear or the use of materials not typically found in residential construction.

Financing Product Availability

The financial products available for purchasing or constructing traditional homes are well-established, with clear guidelines and a long history of performance data. In contrast, barndominiums may not fit neatly into the categories defined by conventional mortgage products. This lack of a standardized financing pathway means banks may have to venture into uncharted territory to lend for a barndominium project, something many are reluctant to do without clear guidelines and precedents.

Interest Rates and Loan Terms

When financing for barndominiums is available, it often comes with less favorable terms than those for traditional homes. Higher interest rates and down payment requirements reflect the bank’s perception of higher risk. These conditions can make securing financing more costly for the borrower, potentially offsetting some of the cost savings that make barndominiums attractive in the first place.

When financing a barndominium in 2024, you have several loan options available, each with its own set of terms, interest rates, and eligibility requirements. Here’s a summary of the main financing options:

1. **Conventional Loans**:
– Offered by banks, credit unions, and national lenders.
– Require a down payment (usually between 3% and 20%) and have terms usually between 15 and 30 years.
– The exact terms and interest rates vary by lender.

2. **VA Loans** (for veterans or active military members):
– Require no down payment and no mortgage insurance.
– Offer lower interest rates compared to conventional loans.
– Have specific eligibility criteria, but no minimum credit score requirement.
– Feature limits on lender charges for closing costs to 1% of the loan【6†source】.
– The VA guarantees these loans, making them less risky for lenders【9†source】.

3. **USDA Loans** (for rural areas):
– Require no down payment.
– Include an upfront fee (typically 1% of the total loan amount) and an annual fee (usually 0.35% of the remaining principal balance), which are generally lower than FHA and conventional mortgage insurance premiums【7†source】.
– Offer the possibility to finance both land and construction costs【7†source】.
– Eligibility depends on the location and household income, with specific debt-to-income ratio limits【7†source】.

4. **FHA Loans**:
– Can cover land, permits, construction, and building materials.
– Require small down payments of just 3.5%.
– Have stringent requirements for qualifying【8†source】.

When considering financing for a barndominium, it’s crucial to understand the various types of loans available and their respective requirements and benefits. For instance, conventional loans often necessitate a substantial down payment and good credit, while USDA and VA loans offer no down payment options, which can be particularly beneficial for certain buyers.

Additionally, when applying for a loan, lenders will evaluate your credit worthiness, the property’s location, and detailed plans for the construction, including fixtures, amenities, and finishes. It’s important to be prepared with all necessary documentation and a clear understanding of your budget and financing needs【5†source】.

Interest rates and loan terms can vary widely based on the type of loan, the lender, and the borrower’s credit profile, among other factors. Therefore, it’s advisable to research thoroughly and compare different loan options and lenders to find the best fit for your financial situation and housing needs.

Navigating the Challenges

For prospective barndominium owners, understanding these challenges is the first step in navigating them. Working with lenders who have experience in non-traditional properties or seeking out specialized financial institutions that offer products tailored for barndominiums can be beneficial. Additionally, preparing a detailed appraisal report, including comps of similar properties if available, and presenting a clear, compliant plan addressing zoning and regulatory requirements can help mitigate some of the concerns lenders may have.

In conclusion, while financing a barndominium can be more complex than securing a mortgage for a traditional home, it’s not impossible. Awareness of the issues and proactive engagement with potential lenders can pave the way for financing these unique and increasingly popular homes.

Why Don't Banks Like Barndominiums? (2024)


Why Don't Banks Like Barndominiums? ›

Marketability and Resale Value

Why are barndominiums hard to finance? ›

Getting a home loan for a barndominium can be tricky since many lenders are unfamiliar with these types of structures. However, it is far from impossible. You just need to be able to fulfill your lender's requirements as well as the stipulations set out by your particular loan program.

Why you should not build a barndominium? ›

List of the Cons of a Barndominium
  • Barndominiums are not immune to corrosion. ...
  • There is still a cost element to consider with barndominiums. ...
  • Some cities may not allow you to build a barndominium. ...
  • Most barndominiums are single-story homes. ...
  • You don't receive the same perks as you would with the typical condo community.
Dec 30, 2023

What is bad about barndominiums? ›

Pros of barndominiums include a cheaper cost, fully customizable space, and lower maintenance. They're also highly durable with lots of extra room and are a more eco-friendly housing option. Meanwhile, cons include higher upfront costs, difficulties finding financing, and not all cities allow them.

Can you get an FHA loan to build a barndominium? ›

Some of the more common loan types (FHA, VA) may not be available if you're trying to build a Barndominium. The lack of comparable sales (for the appraisal process) in the market usually prohibits the use of these types of loans. Luckily, conventional construction loans are available, as are a couple of other options.

What credit score do you need for a barndominium? ›

While criteria varies between institutions, ideal credit scores for the best barndominium loan rates start around 720+ or higher. This provides more assurance to lenders given barndos don't yet have comprehensive comparable sales data that appraisers prefer.

Are barndominiums bad investments? ›

As such, it is more difficult to assess the resale value of a Barndominium. Unlike modular homes and trailers, Barndominiums maintain their value and are likely to increase over time. If you are purely looking for a quick resale investment, a Barndominium may not be your best option.

What do I wish I knew before building a barndominium? ›

Here are the most important things to know about building a barndominium.
  • Obtain a permit for your project. Photo by Bridger Steel, Inc. ...
  • Test the paint. Photo by Justin Doyle Homes. ...
  • Prepare for surprise costs. ...
  • Plan for electrical work. ...
  • Choose your windows and doors wisely. ...
  • Add insulation—it's important.
Mar 14, 2022

Is it hard to insure a barndominium? ›

Insurance can be complicated for barndominium homes. According to Barndominium.org, not all insurers cover barndos, especially if they're mixed-use instead of residential only, and those that do might have barndo-specific policies.

What is the life expectancy of a barndominium? ›

Longevity: Although they may not last as long as traditional homes, a well-maintained barndominium can provide comfortable living for around 50 years. 5. Durability: Barndominiums are built to withstand the elements, ensuring they remain sturdy and reliable over the years.

Are barndominiums prone to mold? ›

Barndominiums offer a blend of rustic aesthetics and modern living that appeals to many homeowners. However, like any other type of construction, they are susceptible to mold growth if not properly designed, constructed, and maintained.

Is it cheaper to build a barndominium or a house? ›

The most common estimate asserts that a new barndominium with basic amenities will cost about $30 to $40 per square foot to build, compared to the cost of building a traditional home is around $100 to $200 per square foot.

Are barndominiums good in hot weather? ›

Barndominiums can indeed be a good option for hot weather, provided they are designed with the climate in mind. Proper insulation, ventilation, and the use of reflective materials are key factors in ensuring these homes remain cool and comfortable even during the hottest months.

How do people finance barndominiums? ›

You can apply for a traditional mortgage loan to finance your barndominium, but it's essential to meet the lender's requirements, such as credit score, income, and down payment. Your property appraisal will play a significant role in determining your loan amount.

How do you turn a barndominium into a house? ›

  1. Pour a foundation. The vast majority of old barns have dirt floors. ...
  2. Rebuild the frame. Chances are the barn's original framing has warped over the years, so you're going to have to replace most of it. ...
  3. Reroof. ...
  4. Install plumbing, electricity, and HVAC. ...
  5. Insulate. ...
  6. Interior finish work.
May 2, 2022

Does Fannie Mae allow barndominiums? ›

For Fannie Mae to finance a barndominium, the property must conform to the area's housing standards and be marketable as a residential property. This means it should not deviate significantly in terms of quality, condition, or materials from other residential properties in the neighborhood.

How hard is it to get a loan to build a barndominium? ›

Difficulty obtaining USDA loan: Though far from impossible, obtaining a USDA loan for a barndominium may be challenging. Many USDA lenders are unfamiliar with these structures and may be reluctant to finance their purchase.

Why are barndominiums so expensive? ›

The biggest cost of building a barndominium comes from purchasing and building the metal shell, including the roof, doors, and windows.

Is buying a barndominium worth it? ›

Barndominiums have the strength and durability that comes with being made from metal, making them just as safe or even more secure than a traditional home. The structural integrity of a barndominium also makes them last longer with less maintenance.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Edwin Metz

Last Updated:

Views: 6052

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (58 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Edwin Metz

Birthday: 1997-04-16

Address: 51593 Leanne Light, Kuphalmouth, DE 50012-5183

Phone: +639107620957

Job: Corporate Banking Technician

Hobby: Reading, scrapbook, role-playing games, Fishing, Fishing, Scuba diving, Beekeeping

Introduction: My name is Edwin Metz, I am a fair, energetic, helpful, brave, outstanding, nice, helpful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.