Clover Club co*cktail - a classic drink recipe from Nerds with Knives (2024)

April 27, 2021February 10, 2021 by Emily

Yes, this pink, frothy co*cktail is perfect for a romantic Valentine’s celebration but don’t let its good looks fool you, the Clover Club is a serious drink. And one originally imbibed exclusively by men – specifically the literary, legal, and financial men who, from 1882 until the 1920’s, met once a month in Philadelphia. The drink, named after their gentlemen’s club, was published in the New York Press in 1901. It called for gin, lemon juice, sugar, raspberry syrup, and egg white. Fast forward to modern times, and it’s also the name of a gorgeous co*cktail bar in our old Brooklyn neighborhood. This new Clover Club, the bar, is where we first sampled Clover Club, the drink.

History of the Clover Club

The Clover Club — the original dinner club, that is — met at first at Philadelphia’s Girard Hotel before moving into their regular room at the original Bellevue Hotel. Oscar Wilde was invited to its first official gathering, but did not attend. Both ex-President Grover Cleveland and the famed actor of the time Sir Henry Irving were honorary members. The club’s very first menu (as published by Mary Deacon, daughter of one of the founders of the club) was as follows. (No actual Clover Club co*cktails here yet, of course.)

Berries in Winter?

We don’t often recommend recipes with out-of-season ingredients but let’s be honest. It’s the middle of winter in the Hudson Valley. There’s not much in season, and sometimes you gotta import a little sunshine (literally, it’s been snowing for four days. We need help). So we wouldn’t recommend making our Strawberry-Lemon Tiramisu this month because that recipe relies on fresh, flavorful berries. However, for a syrup, imported or frozen berries will work just fine.We had a bumper crop of raspberries this summer, so this drink was perfect for using up the last few cups of the berries we froze in July.

At some point in its history, recipes for the Clover Club began to call for grenadine in place of the raspberry but to our taste buds, that’s a poor substitution. A drink this simple needs the sweet-tart freshness that real berries deliver. Paired with gin’s botanicals and fresh lemon juice, it’s more complex than you might expect. The version we had at Clover Club (the bar) also had vermouth in the mix, and we like the dry, slightly bitter note it adds to the drink. (Of course you could leave it out if you prefer.)

The Raspberry Syrup

We like to make enough syrup for several rounds of drinks (because, duh) but you could halve the recipe if you only want enough for a few. The syrup is a cinch to make. Gently simmer the berries, sugar and water for a few minutes, making sure to mash the berries with a muddler or a spoon to extract all the flavor. Once it’s ready, strain it through a fine mesh sieve. Lightly press on the solids to extract as much of the liquid as you can. Don’t smush too hard or the syrup will become cloudy. You can store the syrup in an airtight container in the refrigerator for 2 to 3 weeks.

Egg White or Aquafaba

Many classic co*cktails, like the Gin Fizz and Whisky Sour, use egg whites to give the drink a creamy feel and a frothy top. We love how it mellows a drink and gives it a lovely texture, like in our Brown-Sugar Bourbon co*cktail with Thyme and Lemon which we call The Monarch.

A tip for measuring tricky egg whites is to gently beat them with a fork, just enough to break up the protein strands. This makes it easier to measure out the 1/2 ounce needed for each drink. If you’re making two drinks, 1 oz is pretty much a whole large egg white.

If you’re not comfortable with raw egg or want a vegan option, the liquid from a can of chickpeas (aquafaba) is a perfect substitute. We found that one ounce of aquafaba per drink gave us a nice foamy top. It’s not quite as rich and frothy as the egg white but not bad at all.

The Dry Shake

In order to get the foamiest result in your co*cktail, you’re going to want to do a dry shake. That means shaking all the ingredients together for about 15 seconds without ice first. This lets the long protein strands in the egg white begin to tangle and foam, before the ice is added.

Then ice is added and the drink is shaken again for 30 seconds (the second or wet shake), which chills and dilutes it. Once the drink is strained into a glass, it will have a thick frothy layer on top.

The Recipe