Wooden Barndomoniums Or Metal? Why Metal Barndos Are Better (2024)

Which is better: wooden barndominiums or metal barndominiums? This question has become quite popular as more and more people look for housing options that are low-cost and energy-efficient, not to mention easy to install in a hurry.

Barndominiums are large structures that were originally intended for storage but have been converted into a living space. In short, barndominiums are large barns with a living space added to them.

So, whats’s the deal with barndominiums (also known as “barndos”)? Where did barndominiums come from and why are they so popular?

We’ll answer those questions for you throughout this article so read on!

When Were Barndominiums Invented?

The concept of barndominiums started to become popular in 2106 after its appearance on the popular HGTV show, Fixer Upper, when Chip and Joanna showed off a fabulous barndominium conversion.

However, the term “barndominium” was first coined by Karl Nilsen in the 1980s. Nilsen, a real estate developer, was working on a new kind of planned community that allowed horse owners to live near their horses. It’s the same idea as a golf course community but applied to horses and their owners.

Wooden Barndomoniums Or Metal? Why Metal Barndos Are Better (1)

Why Barndominiums Are Popular

When you first hear about it, the idea of a barndominium might seem like it would only appeal to Texans. However, there are hundreds of people who choose to build a barndominium for reasons other than the red barn motif.

The open space means lots of room

If you have a large family or like to entertain big parties, you’ve probably thought to yourself at one point or another, “We need more room in this place!”. Because barndominiums are being repurposed from barns, which are designed to accommodate large storage needs, they are perfect for fitting large families who want to stay close but keep their sanity.

A quick way to get a connected garage

Barndominiums are also great for installing a covered garage next to your home. This can be handy if you want to keep your vehicle safe or if you use a covered garage for work purposes. For example, someone who fixes cars or has a workshop can keep their workspace near home. Imagine being able to walk a few feet to work and avoiding the usual traffic hassles in the morning!

A quicker build time

If you’re repurposing a metal barn into a barndominium, then the time it takes to build your new barndominium home will be much faster than the build timeframe of a regular house. In fact, most metal barn homes can be built within two weeks.

How is this fast build time possible? Well, when you build a metal barn home like a barndominium, you’ll use pre-assembled steel building kits. This means that all you (or your contractor) need to do is assemble the pieces when they arrive at the site of your new home.

Ideal for remote work setups

If you work from home, you know that it can be hard to get any work done. It’s common for those who work from their home to struggle with staying on task because there is no clear distinction between their home office and the rest of their home. A barndominium solves this problem by letting you build a home office that’s close to home, but separate enough to let you focus and get things done.

Energy-efficiency & eco-friendliness

Another reason people choose to build a barndominium for their home is that metal buildings can be a great option for energy efficiency. Most steel building contractors allow you to use environmentally friendly products as they build their steel buildings so you have the benefit of reducing your carbon footprint. Also, insulating a steel building properly can help you save on heating and cooling costs, lowering your energy bill each month. Features like energy-efficient windows will add to your metal home’s energy efficiency.

Are Wooden Barndominiums Worth It?

If you’ve been doing any research on your future barndominium, you’ve likely encountered the whole “wood or steel” question. It can be frustrating to try to sort out whether using wooden components or steel building components will be best for you.

First of all, it’s worth noting that the wooden components needed to build a barndominium are quite inexpensive compared to steel building components. When you buy the materials for a wooden barndo, you’re likely going to pay less than you would pay for a metal building.

Wood buildings are also much better at absorbing sounds than metal buildings because of it’s material composition and structure. In a metal building, outside sounds can creep in and can be distracting or annoying for those who live there.

Why Metal Barndominiums Are Better Than Wooden Barndos

Wooden Barndomoniums Or Metal? Why Metal Barndos Are Better (2)

Modern steel buildings allow for metal barns to be used as homes that combine the usual storage area with a comfortable living area, usually situated above or near the storage area. Unlike their wooden barn counterparts, metal barndominiums are constructed with steel frames and have steel metal siding. The large, open structural features make them an ideal choice for designing an interior living space that’s comfortable and modern.

Using a metal building for building your barndominium is a much better choice than wood because steel buildings are much easier to install and do not require repainting every couple of years as wooden barndos do.

Want A Metal Barn? Contact California All Steel!

Wooden Barndomoniums Or Metal? Why Metal Barndos Are Better (3)

Searching for the perfect metal building for your barndo? Call us or send us a quote request to learn about our superior steel buildings. As a leading West Coast manufacturer of steel buildings, California All Steel offers superior steel building products that provide you with a strong and durable option for your building projects. Contact us today to learn more!

Wooden Barndomoniums Or Metal? Why Metal Barndos Are Better (2024)

FAQs

Wooden Barndomoniums Or Metal? Why Metal Barndos Are Better? ›

Using a metal building for building your barndominium is a much better choice than wood because steel buildings are much easier to install and do not require repainting every couple of years as wooden barndos do.

Is it cheaper to build a barn with wood or metal? ›

There are two reasons that a metal barn will cost less than a wood structure. First, the materials are less expensive, since you need less material overall to build a metal barn. Additionally, there is a shorter construction process for this kind of building, meaning you won't need to spend as much on labor.

What is the best type of metal building for a barndominium? ›

Steel represents the ideal choice for barndominium builders, as it strikes the perfect balance of being cost-effective, quick to erect, and exceptionally durable. When you consider the pros and cons of all of the options available to you, steel wins out in just about every category.

How long does a metal barndominium last? ›

Proper insulation and high-quality roofing materials can also extend the life of the structure. Depending on the materials used, a well-maintained barndominium can last anywhere from 50 to over 100 years.

Is it cheaper to build a house with wood or metal? ›

Metal tends to be cheaper than wood, with an average of $19-$25 per sq ft for a steel building and $20-$35 per sq ft for a wood building. Also, using metal in your build has a lower lifetime cost due to near-zero maintenance, and it can be nearly 100% salvaged and sold if it is ever torn down.

Is metal or wood barndominium better? ›

Using a metal building for building your barndominium is a much better choice than wood because steel buildings are much easier to install and do not require repainting every couple of years as wooden barndos do.

Is it better to build with wood or metal? ›

After examining all of the factors that go into purchasing an outbuilding kit, we recommend a steel structure over traditional building materials like wood. While upfront costs tend to favor wood construction, the long-term stability of a steel building will win out over time.

What is the most expensive part of a barndominium? ›

Steel framing, popular in barndominium construction for its durability and resistance to pests, can be more expensive than traditional wood framing. Framing costs can range from $20 to $50 per square foot, making it one of the most significant portions of the construction budget.

What is the most cost-effective barndominium size? ›

Generally the most cost-effective barndominium size falls between 1,500-2,500 square feet. The Average size Barndominium in the US falls around 2500sqft as well.

What heats up a barndominium the best? ›

Opting for radiant floor heating in a barndominium ensures even heat distribution without the need for bulky radiators or intrusive ductwork. Ductless mini-split systems provide an energy-efficient solution for barndominiums with diverse living areas.

What is the downside to a barndominium? ›

Pros of barndominiums include a cheaper cost, fully customizable space, and lower maintenance. They're also highly durable with lots of extra room and are a more eco-friendly housing option. Meanwhile, cons include higher upfront costs, difficulties finding financing, and not all cities allow them.

What do I wish I knew before building a barndominium? ›

Here are the most important things to know about building a barndominium.
  • Obtain a permit for your project. Photo by Bridger Steel, Inc. ...
  • Test the paint. Photo by Justin Doyle Homes. ...
  • Prepare for surprise costs. ...
  • Plan for electrical work. ...
  • Choose your windows and doors wisely. ...
  • Add insulation—it's important.
Mar 14, 2022

Why are barndominiums hard to finance? ›

Banks require appraisals to determine the property's value, which in turn, informs their lending decisions. Because barndominiums are relatively unique and fewer in number compared to traditional homes, finding comparable sales (comps) necessary for accurate valuation is difficult.

What lasts longer, steel or wood? ›

Wood sheds and buildings simply don't last as long and are not nearly as sturdy as steel structures. In terms of longevity, steel buildings often last decades longer than wooden structures.

Why are houses built with wood instead of metal? ›

Experts say that many homeowners and building companies in the United States prefer the flexibility of the material, as it can withstand low-intensity natural disasters and weather events such as earthquakes, storms, and hurricanes.

Is a wood building better than a metal building? ›

As mentioned before, wood can warp, rot, crack, and more, which will require expensive replacements when damage occurs. The lifetime maintenance of prefab metal buildings is minimal because steel does not split, rot, or warp like wood. Plus, the warranties on metal roofs and other components last 40 to 50 years.

What is the best material to build a barn? ›

Insulated Concrete Forms (ICF)

While concrete and barns don't seem to go together on the surface, insulated concrete walls and reinforced concrete are the perfect barn construction materials because they offer a huge advantage over timber framing and prefab metal: thermal efficiency and strength.

Which is better, a wood or metal pole barn? ›

Metal provides greater structural strength, making it suitable for larger and taller buildings. Metal frames are inherently more fire-resistant than wood frames, reducing the risk of fire damage. Metal frames offer more design flexibility and can accommodate various architectural styles and building requirements.

Which is cheaper wood or metal framing? ›

Wood studs are generally less expensive than metal studs. Market fluctuations in the price of wood can make the metal studs' price more competitive. Metal studs can only be used with screws, which cost more than framing nails.

Is metal or wood siding better for barn? ›

Metal roofing and siding is far more durable, with lower maintenance needs than wood. As a result, someone could expect a metal roof or siding to last as much as 50 years with little to no maintenance.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Chrissy Homenick

Last Updated:

Views: 5541

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (54 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Chrissy Homenick

Birthday: 2001-10-22

Address: 611 Kuhn Oval, Feltonbury, NY 02783-3818

Phone: +96619177651654

Job: Mining Representative

Hobby: amateur radio, Sculling, Knife making, Gardening, Watching movies, Gunsmithing, Video gaming

Introduction: My name is Chrissy Homenick, I am a tender, funny, determined, tender, glorious, fancy, enthusiastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.